Friday, September 25, 2026

Extreme Solar Particle Events (ESPEs)

An article in Science alert on sunspots and solar flares (https://www.sciencealert.com/sunspot-40-times-wider-than-earth-shows-our-sun-is-capable-of-superflares) led me to doing a little research using Gemini AI. Here's what I found, These are the major events recorded in tree rings:
Obviously such events are far from being a regular occurrence but they do happen. For comparison a more recent event such as the  Carrington Event of September 1859 is too small an event to show up on this chart.

Carrington Event September 1859
A solar storm which caused the telegraph system — the only large-scale electrical network in existence at the time — to function as a massive antenna for geomagnetically induced currents (GICs) which caused massive surges through telegraph wires. Sparks jumped from equipment, setting fire to telegraph station switchboards and burning rolls of paper tape. Several telegraph operators in North America and Europe received severe electrical shocks when touching their keys or metal apparatus.

I asked Gemini about the events on the chart:

That 12,350 BCE event stands out. If such an event occured today what would be the effect on civilization?

An extreme solar particle event on the scale of the ~12,350 BCE event—estimated to have had an integral proton fluence of roughly for energies , or nearly double the 774 CE benchmark—would represent an existential shock to modern technological infrastructure.

Unlike a pure geomagnetic storm (which primarily couples with long conductors on the ground), an ESPE of this magnitude combines extreme geomagnetic induction with an intense bombardment of relativistic solar energetic particles (SEPs).

1. Near-Total Loss of Orbital Infrastructure

  • Direct Solar Array & Electronics Destruction: High-energy protons () penetrate satellite shielding easily. They cause fatal single-event burnouts in microprocessors and degrade photovoltaic panels through lattice displacement.

  • Loss of Constellations: Low Earth Orbit (LEO) constellations (Starlink, OneWeb, Earth-observation networks) and Medium/Geostationary satellites (GPS, Galileo, communications) would suffer massive, simultaneous hardware bricking.

  • Severe Atmospheric Drag: Upper atmospheric heating causes the thermosphere to expand rapidly upward. Thousands of LEO satellites and debris objects would experience dramatic, unpredicted orbital decay, causing collisions and uncontrolled re-entries.

  • Manned Spaceflight: Astronauts aboard the International Space Station or future lunar missions caught outside deep radiation shelters would receive lethal doses of radiation (tens of Sieverts) within hours.

2. Multi-Continent Power Grid Collapse

  • Geomagnetically Induced Currents (GICs): The associated coronal mass ejection (CME) shock front would violently compress the magnetosphere. Ground-induced quasi-DC currents would saturate extra-high-voltage (EHV) step-up transformer cores.

  • Transformer Meltdown: Transformer cores would overheat within minutes due to severe stray magnetic flux, destroying insulating paper and causing explosive dielectric oil fires.

  • Global Replacement Bottleneck: High-voltage transmission transformers are custom-built, weigh hundreds of tonnes, and have normal manufacturing lead times of 18 to 36 months. Losing hundreds across North America, Europe, and Asia simultaneously would take regional electric grids offline for months, and in severe cases, years.

3. Atmosphere & Environmental Degradation

  • Severe Ozone Depletion: Energetic protons breaking into the stratosphere dissociate molecular nitrogen and oxygen, generating huge quantities of odd nitrogen () and odd hydrogen () catalytic radicals. Studies model a 30% to 50% global loss of the ozone layer, persisting for several years.

  • Surface UV-B Spike: Biologically damaging solar UV-B flux reaching the surface would surge, increasing rates of DNA damage in crops, collapsing oceanic phytoplankton blooms at the base of marine food webs, and causing severe skin damage/blindness in wildlife and livestock. Humans, especially those with fair skin, would experience sunburn and an increase of cataracts and skin cancers for the next 1 - 5 years while the ozone layer recovered.

  • Ground-Level Radiation: While air mass provides equivalent shielding to ~10 meters of water, the high-energy muon/neutron cascade at sea level would cause a Ground Level Enhancement (GLE) with radiation doses equivalent to several hundred chest X-rays over several days—non-lethal to humans on the surface, but elevated for commercial airline flights at cruising altitude. Airflight would have to be grounded during the event.

4. Cascade Failures Across Critical Societal Systems

  • Global Communications: High-frequency (HF) radio propagation would be blacked out globally via polar cap absorption (PCA) and global D-region ionization. Undersea fiber-optic cables might survive, but their transcontinental terrestrial landing stations and grid-dependent repeater power networks would fail.

  • Supply Chains & Food Distribution: Without electric grids, municipal water treatment and pumping halt within 24–48 hours. Fuel pumps at distribution terminals stop working, freezing road and rail logistics for food, medicines, and diesel for emergency backup generators.

  • Global Economic Shock: Modern financial ledgers, transactional clearinghouses, and telecommunications rely on nanosecond-precision atomic clock signals from GPS/GNSS. A loss of constellation synchronization combined with power outages would halt global trade, banking, and inventory systems instantly.

  • You could expect to lose,  Internet, phone service, banking, electrical power, GPS. That would cause massive supply chain disruption and starvation.

An event of the 12,350 BCE magnitude would not quite return humanity to the Stone Age biologically, but it would forcibly decouple civilization from modern electrical and satellite architectures, triggering an emergency humanitarian crisis driven by supply-chain and power restoration timelines.


What about a less powerful event such as the 1279 CE event?

An event on the scale of the 1279 CE event—producing a excursion of roughly (about one-fifth the magnitude of the 12,350 BCE event)—would still be approximately 5 to 10 times more intense in high-energy proton fluence than any solar particle event observed during the space age, including the major October 1989 solar proton storms.

Rather than causing an outright collapse of civilization, an event of this scale would cause severe, widespread infrastructure damage, orbital attrition, and significant economic disruption, but within thresholds modern engineering could survive if standard mitigations and protocols were deployed.

1. Satellites and Orbital Spacecraft

  • High Rate of Satellite Losses: Unhardened commercial electronics (especially commercial-off-the-shelf components in Low Earth Orbit mega-constellations) would suffer extensive Single-Event Effects (SEEs), latch-ups, and dielectric electrostatic discharges. A noticeable fraction of LEO constellations would be disabled or lose attitude control.

  • Rapid Solar Array Degradation: Solar cells would suffer immediate, irreversible non-ionizing energy loss (displacement damage), permanently shortening satellite lifespans by months to several years.

  • Navigation and Timing Outages: Medium Earth Orbit (MEO) GPS/Galileo satellites use radiation-hardened parts and would likely survive, but ionospheric scintillation and total electron content (TEC) perturbations would degrade GPS signal locks and positioning accuracy for days to weeks.

  • Crewed Spaceflight: Space stations in low-inclination orbits would receive substantial radiation spikes; crews would need to shelter in high-mass shielding compartments (such as water-lined service modules) to prevent acute radiation sickness.

2. Terrestrial Power Grids

  • Severe Geomagnetically Induced Currents (GICs): If paired with an energetic Coronal Mass Ejection (CME) shock, GICs would stress high-voltage networks—especially at high geomagnetic latitudes (e.g., Canada, Scandinavia, northern UK, and the northern US).

  • Local Transformer Damage vs. Systemic Failure: Unlike the 12,350 BCE scenario, modern grid operators with automated protective relaying and 12–24 hours of space-weather warning could avoid catastrophic global meltdowns. Instead, expect managed rolling blackouts, selective line trips, and localized transformer burnouts where geology creates high ground conductivity contrasts.

  • Recovery Timeline: Regional outages would likely last days to a few weeks, rather than the multi-year manufacturing bottleneck of an unmitigated mega-storm.

3. Atmospheric and Environmental Effects

  • Moderate Polar Ozone Thinning: The solar proton influx would create catalytic and radicals primarily in the mesosphere and upper stratosphere over the polar caps. Polar ozone could temporarily drop by 10% to 20% for 1–2 years before atmospheric circulation dilutes and restores normal chemistry.

  • Commercial Aviation Rerouting: Flights on transpolar and high-latitude routes would need to be grounded or rerouted to lower latitudes immediately to prevent crews and passengers from receiving high occupational radiation doses and to avoid high-frequency (HF) polar cap communication blackouts.

  • Surface Radiation: High-energy neutron cascades at ground level (Ground Level Enhancements) would be readily detectable by global neutron monitors, but surface radiation levels would remain well below levels hazardous to biological health.

4. Communications and Electronics

  • Radio Blackouts: High-frequency (HF) marine and aircraft communications would be completely blocked across polar and auroral latitudes for days due to intense D-region ionization (Polar Cap Absorption).

  • Subsea and Terrestrial Data: Undersea fiber-optic cables would function normally, though power-feed equipment at landing sites connected to volatile local grids could experience brief dropouts.

  • Everyday Consumer Electronics: Smartphones, desktop computers, cars, and consumer electronics at ground level would remain completely unaffected; the mass of Earth's atmosphere () provides total shielding against direct particle penetration.

In summary, a 1279 CE-scale event would be an orbital disaster and an expensive grid stress-test costing tens to hundreds of billions of dollars globally, but it would be a manageable industrial emergency rather than an existential threat to society.